Sort every negative Amazon feedback against Amazon's removal rules, then act on each one
Updated · By Ecomsellertool editorial team
Amazon removes seller feedback only for set reasons: profanity, hate speech, personal information, a comment that is entirely a product review, a product sold by another seller, or a product you own the brand of. It strikes through FBA delivery complaints and on-time Buy Shipping delays. Request it in Feedback Manager within 90 days; the rest gets a public reply or a permitted buyer message.
- Amazon removes feedback that contains profanity, hate speech or personal information, references a product sold by a different seller, or is entirely a product review (checked November 20, 2026).
- A comment that mixes a product review with feedback about your service is not removed.
- Removal requests go through Feedback Manager only, within 90 days of the feedback; Amazon says other channels may lead to account deactivation.
- Only 1- and 2-star feedback counts toward Order Defect Rate, which applies to seller-fulfilled orders and must stay under 1% over 60 days.
- You may contact the buyer through Buyer-Seller Messaging to resolve the problem, but you may not ask them to remove or change feedback or offer anything for it.
- We found no SP-API notification for new feedback; the feedback report, which lists 1- to 3-star ratings, can only be requested.
The step map: who runs each step
Trigger: A daily request for Amazon's seller feedback report, which lists every negative and neutral rating with its order ID and comment.
| Step | What happens | Who runs it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rules request the feedback report each morning, add each new 1- to 3-star rating as one case keyed by order ID, skip ones already in the queue and stamp the 90-day removal deadline from the feedback date. | Rule |
| 2 | Rules join the order: Amazon-fulfilled or seller-fulfilled, Multi-Channel Fulfillment or not, ship-by date against the first carrier scan, whether the label came from Buy Shipping, delivery status and any buyer messages. | Rule |
| 3 | An AI model reads the comment against Amazon's removal and strike-through reasons, quotes the words that match a reason, and marks any comment that also mentions your service as not eligible. | AI model |
| 4 | Rules match the case to a row of the feedback decision table: removal request, strike-through request, public reply, buyer contact or a fix to the cause, and set the owner and the deadline. | Rule |
| 5 | An AI model drafts the request comment for Amazon, a short public reply with no personal details and no questions, and a buyer message for a permitted purpose that never asks for the feedback to change. | AI model |
| 6 | A person checks each draft against the comment and the order, then submits the request, posts the reply and sends the message in Seller Central themselves. | Person |
| 7 | Rules read the status of each request (Under review, Approved, Denied), alert before the appeal deadline on a denial, and close the case when the rating comes off or the buyer removes it. | Rule |
| 8 | Each week rules count negative feedback by cause, SKU and carrier and recompute the Order Defect Rate with and without the open requests, so the causes get fixed, not only the comments. | Rule |
5 rule steps · 2 AI model steps · 1 person step. A rule follows fixed logic you approve; an AI model handles messy input and its output is checked by rules; a person makes the calls listed below.
What stays with a person
- Every removal or strike-through request submitted in Feedback Manager, and every appeal of a denial
- Every public reply, because it cannot be edited once posted
- Every message to a buyer, and whether to refund or replace
- Which comments not to fight, so speculative requests do not pile up
- The decision table itself: owners, wording rules and which causes get fixed first
Which tools can run it
- A daily feedback report download and a spreadsheet of cases with the 90-day dates, for a few ratings a month
- Zapier, Make or n8n reading the report file, running an AI model step on each comment and posting each case to Slack or a helpdesk
- Custom code on your accounts for the feedback report, order and shipping joins, the classifier and the 90-day clock
Systems it connects
- Seller Central Feedback Manager
- Amazon SP-API seller feedback and seller performance reports
- Amazon SP-API Orders API
- Buyer-Seller Messages
- Shipping software or carrier tracking
- Helpdesk, Slack or a case queue
Build size: Medium
Reading the report is simple; the work is classifying comments against Amazon's exact reasons, joining fulfillment and shipping data per order, and keeping a person on every submission.
A 1-star rating lands on a Tuesday. It says the parcel came late and the box was dented. Nobody opens Feedback Manager until the monthly review, and by then the team is arguing about whether Amazon will remove it. It will not: the comment is about your service, and that is not on Amazon's list. Two weeks earlier, though, a comment that was entirely a product review sat unchallenged past its window. This recipe reads every negative and neutral rating the day it arrives, sorts it against Amazon's own rules and puts the right action in front of one person. It is one page of our automation library.
Which Amazon feedback can be removed, and what do you do with the rest?
Start with a written table, because each kind of comment has one right action. The removal and strike-through rows below are the only ones Amazon lists on its Can Amazon remove buyer feedback? page and its FBA feedback page (both checked November 20, 2026). The request path and the 90-day window come from Amazon's request feedback review page (checked November 20, 2026). The evidence column is our suggestion for what to save with each case.
| Kind of feedback | Does Amazon remove it? | How to request | Evidence to keep | Window | If not removable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profanity, obscenity or language inappropriate in public | Yes, removed | Feedback Manager, Request review, pick the matching reason | A screenshot of the comment, the order ID, the feedback date | 90 days from the feedback | Not needed; if denied, appeal from Manage Review Requests |
| Hate speech | Yes, removed | Same; Amazon also points abusive feedback to Report a violation | Same, with the words that match | 90 days | Appeal a denial before its deadline |
| Personal information: emails, full names, phone numbers | Yes, removed | Feedback Manager, Request review | The comment, with the personal details masked in your own records | 90 days | Appeal a denial |
| The entire comment is a product review | Yes, removed | Feedback Manager, Request review | The comment and the listing it describes | 90 days | Not needed |
| A product review plus a comment on your service | No, Amazon says it stays | None | The comment, the order and its shipping record | None | Fix the service cause, post a public reply, contact the buyer to resolve it |
| References a product sold by a different seller | Yes, removed | Feedback Manager, Request review | Your order record showing what you sold and shipped | 90 days | Appeal a denial |
| Related to a product you are the brand owner or authorized reseller for | Yes, Amazon lists it as a removal reason | Feedback Manager, Request review | The comment and the product it names | 90 days | Appeal a denial |
| Amazon-fulfilled (FBA) order, the entire comment is about delivery | Struck through, with Amazon's note that it takes responsibility | Feedback Manager, Request review | The order's fulfillment channel | 90 days | If any part is about product condition or your own service, it stays: reply and fix |
| Seller-fulfilled order shipped on time with Buy Shipping, the entire comment is about a delay or non-delivery | Struck through, with Amazon's note that the seller was not at fault | Feedback Manager, Request review | The Buy Shipping label, ship date against the ship-by date, tracking | 90 days | A late or non-Buy Shipping label: fix the carrier or handling time, reply publicly |
| Multi-Channel Fulfillment order | No strike-through, Amazon says | None | The order | None | Treat it as seller-fulfilled: reply and contact |
| Unhappy with delivery speed on your own label | No, not on Amazon's list | None | Ship date, first scan, carrier delay | None | Reply publicly; if the delay came from outside events such as customs, Amazon suggests saying so in the reply |
| Unhappy with the product or your service, no rule broken | No, Amazon keeps feedback that follows its policies | None | The order, messages, any refund | None | Contact the buyer to resolve it; the buyer may remove it within 60 days of leaving it |
Two rows decide most of the work. The removal rows are narrow: a single sentence about your service in an otherwise product-only comment takes it out of the table. And the delivery rows depend on facts in your shipping data, not in the comment, which is why the workflow joins the order before it judges anything. Amazon's FBA page also warns against high volumes of incorrect or speculative requests, so the table sends "no" rows to a reply, not to a hopeful request.
How much can removal requests move your Order Defect Rate?
Amazon's Order Defect Rate page (checked November 20, 2026) counts orders with negative feedback, an A-to-z claim or a service chargeback over 60 days. Only 1- and 2-star feedback counts, the rate applies only to seller-fulfilled orders, and sellers must stay under 1%. Negative feedback is matched to the order date, not the date the feedback arrived. Amazon's removal page says a granted request takes the feedback's impact off both your feedback rating and your Order Defect Rate.
Here is an illustrative month, not a client result. A brand has 3,000 seller-fulfilled orders in the 60-day window, with 25 orders carrying negative feedback, 6 A-to-z claims and 2 chargebacks, all on different orders. That is 33 defective orders, or 1.1%, above Amazon's line.
| Step | Count | Order Defect Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Defective orders before any request (25 + 6 + 2) | 33 of 3,000 | 1.1% |
| New feedback this month: 22 negative (of the 25 above), 8 neutral | 30 | Neutral (3-star) does not count |
| Negative ones that match a removal reason: 4 product reviews, 1 with a phone number, 1 with profanity | 6 | |
| Negative ones about delay only, shipped on time with Buy Shipping | 3 | |
| Negative ones with no removal reason | 13 | |
| If Amazon grants all 9 requests (33 − 9) | 24 of 3,000 | 0.8% |
| If Amazon grants only 5 (33 − 5) | 28 of 3,000 | 0.93% |
The arithmetic checks: 6 + 3 + 13 = 22 negative ratings. One neutral rating was also a product review; a request there lifts the feedback score but not the defect rate. The lesson is the 13. Most negative feedback does not qualify, so the same queue that files requests also has to send causes, late carriers and damaged packaging, to the people who can fix them. Our account health agent watches the rate itself; this queue works the ratings that move it, next to the A-to-z claim response queue for claims.
What may you say to a buyer who left negative feedback?
You may help, but you may not ask for the feedback. Amazon's resolve or respond page (checked November 20, 2026) encourages you to contact the buyer to fix the problem, and calls pressuring or incentivizing them to remove or change feedback a policy violation. Its page on buyers removing feedback (checked November 20, 2026) adds that contact must use Buyer-Seller Messaging, about an order or a service question, with no request to remove feedback and no incentive. The seller code of conduct (checked November 20, 2026) also bans paying or offering anything for removing feedback.
Amazon's Communication program policy (checked November 20, 2026) sets the rest. Messages you start must go out within 30 days of the order's completion, carry the full 17-digit order ID, use the buyer's language and fit a listed purpose, such as resolving a fulfillment issue or a return or refund question. It bans language that persuades a buyer to update or delete non-favorable feedback, before or after service, and allows one feedback request per order, only if the buyer has not already left one. So the workflow drafts a fix, a refund offer for a person to approve, or a return answer. It never drafts "would you reconsider your rating". If the buyer removes it on their own, Amazon says it stops counting toward the rate, which can take up to 48 hours.
When should you post a public reply instead?
When the comment stays and the problem is fixed, or cannot be. Amazon's public reply page (checked November 20, 2026) says a reply does not change your feedback score, cannot hold any personal details about you or the buyer, and should not ask questions, because buyers cannot answer it. Once submitted, a reply can be removed but not changed, and the resolve page says that after you delete one you cannot post a second. That is why every reply in this queue is drafted short, read by a person and posted by that person in Feedback Manager.
A good reply says what happened and what changed, in two or three sentences, for the next buyer who reads it. For delays caused by events outside your control, Amazon's removal page suggests a reply that says so. Replies are also where a "mixed" comment goes, since the product half cannot pull the service half out of the rating.
Where does the feedback data come from?
Amazon's performance reports documentation (checked November 20, 2026) lists a feedback report with negative and neutral ratings, one to three stars, with the date, rating, comment, your response and the order ID. Amazon says it can only be requested, so the workflow requests it each morning. We read Amazon's notification types the same day and found no notification for new feedback; seller feedback appears there only as a rating summary inside offer-change events. The same reports page has the seller performance report, whose Order Defect Rate section counts negative feedback separately for Amazon-fulfilled and seller-fulfilled orders, which the weekly recount checks against.
Submitting is a different matter. Amazon says removal requests can only be made through Feedback Manager, and that asking through Contact Us or any other channel may lead to account deactivation. The Messaging API (checked November 20, 2026) lists message types such as order details, delivery details and unexpected problems, none for feedback. So code does the reading, joining and drafting, and a person does every submission. The order joins use the Orders API on your own SP-API authorization, and the shipping facts come from your shipping software or carriers. Merchant-fulfilled brands (FBM) get the most from it, since the defect rate only counts their orders.
What should stay with a person?
Every action Amazon or the buyer will see. Rules can pull the report, join the order and count the days. A model can match the words to a reason and draft text. But Amazon's About Feedback Manager page (checked November 20, 2026) shows requests moving through Under review, Approved and Denied, with an appeal deadline on denials, and each of those is a judgment about one comment. A person also decides which comments are not worth a request, so the account does not build a record of speculative ones.
The person also owns the fix. If the weekly count shows one carrier behind most of the delay comments, that goes to whoever runs carrier rate shopping. If it shows dented boxes, it goes to packing. Delay notices sent before the buyer writes, from your shipping exception alerts, prevent some of these ratings before they are written. Asking for feedback at all, through Amazon's own tool, is covered in our review requests recipe. Low-star product reviews are a separate stream, about the product rather than your service; our low-star review alerts recipe routes each one to whoever can fix its cause.
Which tool should run the queue?
The simplest one that can read the report and see your shipping data.
| Level | Fits when | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Report download and a case spreadsheet | A few negative ratings a month, one shipping tool | Someone has to tag each comment and watch the 90-day dates by hand |
| Zapier, Make or n8n with an AI model step | One store, modest volume, a helpdesk already in use | Keep one case per order ID, log every classification with the words it matched, and never let a step submit anything |
| Custom code on your accounts | Several marketplaces, FBA and FBM mixed, many ratings | Can run on Ecomsellertool Growth OS beside the order and shipping data it needs |
Our guide to automating Amazon operations shows where this queue sits with the rest of the account-health work.
Who builds a feedback removal queue for Amazon sellers?
Ecomsellertool builds feedback queues on your own Seller Central account, shipping software and helpdesk. We have built on Amazon's seller APIs since 2017 and shipped 50+ tools for 100+ teams. We write your decision table with you first, then build the report pull, the order joins, the classifier and the deadline clock, with every submission left to your team. Send a project brief, or read how our workflow automation service works.
Two case studies are close to this work:
- Alerts on negative seller comments. For AccountDr we built rule-based automation that notifies Amazon sellers about negative seller comments, performance metrics, hijackers and listing faults, by push and email, so a person acts on the specific item.
- Buyer messages inside a seller app. The Zquared case study lists an autoresponder that sends automated messages to buyers to collect feedback and product reviews and provide better customer service, next to its profit dashboard.
You keep your accounts, your data and the custom code we build; the Growth OS base is licensed to you. If you are not sure feedback is your biggest leak, the free 24-hour diagnostic looks across the account first.
Get your feedback queue built
Send us how negative feedback reaches your team today
Describe the workflow you want automated. We reply with a written plan: scope, timeline and a fixed price.
Frequently asked questions
Can Amazon remove negative seller feedback?
Yes, but only in set cases. Amazon removes feedback that contains profanity or obscenity, hate speech, or personal information such as emails, full names or phone numbers, feedback that references a product sold by a different seller or a product you are the brand owner or authorized reseller for, and feedback that is entirely a product review. Feedback that follows its policies stays.
How long do I have to request feedback removal on Amazon?
90 days from the day the buyer left the feedback. Amazon's Feedback Manager pages say requests must be made within 90 days of the feedback submission and that the system prevents requests after that. If a request is denied, you can appeal from the Manage Review Requests tab before the deadline shown there.
Will Amazon remove feedback about late delivery?
Only in two cases. For an order fulfilled by Amazon, a comment entirely about the delivery experience can be struck through with Amazon's note that it takes responsibility. For an order you shipped on time with Buy Shipping, a comment entirely about a delayed or undelivered order can be struck through. A late shipment on your own label is not on Amazon's removal list.
Can I ask a buyer to remove negative feedback on Amazon?
No. Amazon's pages say you can contact the buyer through Buyer-Seller Messaging to resolve their problem, but you must not ask them to remove or change negative feedback, and you must not offer compensation or any incentive for positive feedback or removal. The buyer may still choose to remove it, within 60 days of leaving it.
Does removed feedback still count toward my Order Defect Rate?
No. Amazon says that when a removal request is granted, the impact of the feedback is removed from your feedback rating and Order Defect Rate. When a buyer removes negative feedback, it stops counting too, though Amazon says that can take up to 48 hours. Only 1- and 2-star feedback counts toward the rate, which applies to seller-fulfilled orders.
Is there an API to request Amazon feedback removal?
We did not find one on November 20, 2026. Amazon says removal requests can only be made in Feedback Manager. The SP-API gives a feedback report you request on a schedule, with each 1- to 3-star rating, its comment and order ID, but no notification for new feedback and no call that submits a removal request or a public reply.
Should I reply publicly to negative Amazon feedback?
Often, yes, once you have tried to fix the problem. A public reply does not change your rating, but other buyers can read it. Amazon asks you to keep it brief and professional, leave out personal details, and not ask questions, because buyers cannot answer a public reply. You can delete a reply but not edit it.
